Human cloning is it morally acceptable

Human cloning statistics

Why did they do it? Yet we all believe that the arguments presented in the sections that follow are worthy of consideration in the course of trying to assess fully the ethical issues involved. There has been no apparent ill effect of this permission on British society. What is Cloning? Those who favor eugenics and genetic enhancement were once far more open regarding their intentions to enable future generations to enjoy more advantageous genotypes. Besides the dehumanizing prospects of the turn toward manufacture that such programs of enhancement would require, there is the further difficulty of the lack of standards to guide the choices for "improvement. Like our board members, they argue that the benefits of this research and the possible therapies it could produce far outweigh the claims of the activated eggs. Moreover, because the Council is considering cloning within a broad context of present and projected techniques that can affect human procreation or alter the genetic makeup of our children, it is important that we consider the full range and depth of ethical issues raised by such efforts. When we stop to think about the two applications of cloning some troubling questions begin to arise. Instead of using this precedent to justify taking the next step of cloning, the next step might rather serve as a warning and a mirror in which we may discover reasons to reconsider what we are already doing. The arguments introduced above are grounded in the following premises. The end served by IVF is still the same as natural reproduction-the birth of a child from the union of gametes from two progenitors. The nucleus of a human egg would be removed and replaced with a nucleus of a cell from an adult. Should a child bear the burden of knowing, for example, that he was cloned using a somatic cell from a genius such as Einstein? Is it permissible to create such a developing human entity only to destroy it??

Life becomes a cheap, expendable commodity. But cloning is a controversial issue that exposes all research participants to novel risks.

Will humans actually be cloned in the laboratory?

ethics of human cloning pdf

What the exact effects of cloning-to-produce-children might be for families is highly speculative, to be sure, but it is still worth flagging certain troubling possibilities and risks.

Here are the five major questions the board considered before the company went forward with cloning the first human embryo.

Any onslaught against a fellow human being, regardless of his stage of development, is ultimately against God.

Human cloning is it morally acceptable

But opponents, including the Roman Catholic Church, protest that therapeutic cloning will inevitably lead to cloned human beings because the basic scientific method, known as Cell Nuclear Replacement, is exactly the same. Four years earlier Ian Wilmut had made public the successful cloning of Dolly, the sheep whose photograph has been seen all over the world. Is it permissible to create such a developing human entity only to destroy it?? In the present debate about cloning-to-produce-children, the case for eugenics and enhancement is not made openly, but it nonetheless remains an important motivation for some advocates. But the principle that would be established by human cloning is both far-reaching and completely novel: parents, with the help of science and technology, may determine in advance the genetic endowment of their children. Life becomes a cheap, expendable commodity. By shutting down responsible research on the cell biology of human cloning, such a ban would also guarantee that the first efforts at cloning a human being would be based on scanty scientific information. First, a substantial market in human eggs for reproductive purposes already exists.

The problem has to do with the control of the entire genotype and the production of children to selected specifications. This childs cells have not yet been used in a cloning procedure.

how does cloning affect the environment

If a person can agree to undergo a dangerous malaria vaccine study to help cure disease, why should they be prevented from donating eggs for similar lifesaving research?

The key element in ethical liberalism, on the other hand, is the norm that individuals are morally required not to engage in actions that entail harm to other human beings.

To increase that to a number that can be used in research, she must be given stimulatory medications such as those used in reproductive IVF procedures.

human cloning ethical issues essay
Rated 8/10 based on 69 review
PCBE: Human Cloning and Human Dignity: An Ethical Inquiry