A critical evaluate and report of
What do you think about this? The other key element in critical writing is the overall structure of your piece of writing. How do I link my findings to the background research?
The most characteristic features of descriptive writing are that it will describe something, but will not go beyond an account of what appears to be there.
How to critically evaluate literature
A critical read through your own writing may reveal gaps in your logic, which you can rectify before you submit it for the critique of others. The balance will change at different points, but you need to make sure there is enough of the colour that represents critical writing. An assignment using only descriptive writing would therefore gain few marks. You will need to: consider the quality of the evidence and argument you have read; identify key positive and negative aspects you can comment upon; assess their relevance and usefulness to the debate that you are engaging in for your assignment; and identify how best they can be woven into the argument that you are developing. How do I link my findings to the background research? The other key element in critical writing is the overall structure of your piece of writing. What is critical writing?
Look at the example below from John's report. Just as you have used paragraphs on a micro scale to present your critical writing, so you need to consider the ordering of those paragraphs within the overall structure. Why might this be?
This is more challenging and risky. Where he found differences between his results and those of other studies, John tried to find reasons for these differences. Check out the conclusions that you have drawn, then locate and check the supporting evidence you provide earlier on.
There are three main ways of dealing with such statements: present the evidence to support the statement re-phrase the statement to sound more cautious e.
Importance of critical review
Other study guides you may find useful are: What is Critical Reading? Look at the example below from John's report. Beyond that, however, there is a danger that too much descriptive writing will use up valuable words from your word limit, and reduce the space you have for the critical writing that will get you higher marks. The most characteristic features of critical writing are: a clear and confident refusal to accept the conclusions of other writers without evaluating the arguments and evidence that they provide; a balanced presentation of reasons why the conclusions of other writers may be accepted or may need to be treated with caution; a clear presentation of your own evidence and argument, leading to your conclusion; and a recognition of the limitations in your own evidence, argument, and conclusion. In providing only description, you are presenting but not transforming information; you are reporting ideas but not taking them forward in any way. It is important, however, to remember that you also need to interpret the quotes to the reader, and to explain their relevance, discuss their validity, and show how they relate to other evidence. What conclusions can you draw from this? What is descriptive writing? The aim is to lead your readers carefully through the thread of your argument, to a well-supported conclusion. Line of argument So far this study guide has considered the detail of what you write. I expected it to be fewer than that. There must be reasons why the figures are so different.
Dealing with distractions Showing critical analysis According to tutors who mark reports, the discussion of the findings has the most potential for demonstrating critical analysis and gaining high marks. The author refers to the available evidence, but also evaluates the validity of that evidence, and assesses what contribution it can realistically make to the debate.
The department clearly recognises this already as shown by the flexibility of seminar times described earlier. The kinds of questions that might be useful to ask at that stage are: What is the balance between descriptive and critical writing?
based on 97 review